Still photography aiming at telling a story about
people relies heavily on their facial expressions. Street photography, however,
aims at capturing people’s attitudes in an impromptu way while attempting to not
always reveal the identity of the people. Because it is not important who the
people were in a photo – what counts is the story they tell that can be
understood and interpreted by the viewers.
A street photographer aims at capturing moments with
which viewers identify, and avoids identifying the subjects of the photograph
to the extent possible.
So, I took this photo last week. The three persons,
their hands and legs were perfectly aligned and self-composed the shot. Yet
they were distinctly different in their line-up. As I was looking through the
viewfinder of my 1970s Nikon F2, I wondered if their postures reflected their
characters and attitudes.
And, as I often become curious about body language,
I did some research about what the positioning of legs is believed to tell
about the person or the message they are sending with different ways of placing
their feet toward another person or the object of their attention.
I was amazed that there is a lot written about this
topic in the sociological literature. Distilling the proposed interpretations
to a manageable set, here is what seemed of interest to me as a photographer:
1. Managers
who interview applicants are often trained to “read” the body language of the
interviewee. It seems that when a person answers untruthfully to a question,
they make unconscious leg and foot movements.
2. Crossing
the legs seems to tell what the person is open to or reluctant to do. There is the
“standing- leg-cross” implying defensive
posturing in company of people we do not know well. There is the military “legs-apart” showing dominance; there is
the stereotypic “cowboy stand” with
legs apart, feet pointed outward, and thumbs in the belt with the hips pushed
out. There seems to be the “European/British leg cross” where the
left leg is crossed over the right one.
And, there is the “American Figure
Four” leg cross, which is a modified version of the cowboy stand, this time
sitting down but still pushing the pelvis out and placing the hands on the
crossed leg!
3. Not
only legs, but ankles also tell a story…The “lock ankle” position, both in men and women is believed to be
equivalent to “biting the lip”! It is reported that people in courtrooms lock
their ankles, and that more people lock their ankles when dealing with the tax professionals
than they do when in the dentist’s seat…
4. Finally,
there is the “parallel legs” with one
foot’s toes gently locked upon the other leg’s ankle. This is the ultimate
femininity expression, and one that every man on our round globe will recognize
and appreciate!
Ok. So now I was very curious to look through my
photos and see if I had, purposefully or not, captured some body and leg
positioning which may tell a story about the person. My interest in this topic
is not new (https://liveingray.blogspot.com/2014/09/street-photography-from-dogs-perspective.html)
but I felt that now I have more of a scientific template to use when looking
through my photos.
So, here is a sample.
St. Patrick’s Day. Two of an Irish band’s musicians
taking a break. Is this the “cowboy” posture? In fact the man on the right
seems to have more of Greek demi-god feel of the moment….
On the boardwalk looking at sailors in a passing
boat. I do not see any reserved or reluctant body language here.
In Paris, looking like a sailor. The hands on the
hip, a look that says “few discoveries left”. Too bad I did not have her legs
in the frame to make a complete analysis…
Man, woman and poster, Singapore. It all seems to
fit together.
A street embrace. One does not need to read the
sociological literature about body posture to understand this photo.
Cowboys and Saloon ladies, Arizona. This was an
enactment yet I find it interesting that both ladies have crossed their right
legs over the left ones. Is this the “anti-European” cross?
The dreamer posture. This time the toes are inward.
Is this the “I do not notice those around me” posture?
After looking at the last photo, I remembered one
taken by someone else of me on the stage with a colleague in Taiwan. This was
during my “previous life” as an academic as I had just finished my talk at a
conference.
I could not resist including this picture, as my feet seem to be
placed in the most non-nonchalant way, while her toes are turned inward. I did
not know that I place my feet this way, and now have to do some research on
what this means about my attitude to life!
June 8, 2016
© Vahé A. Kazandjian, 2016
My friend, I am wondering what you are doing with your left hand as well!
ReplyDelete